US Treasury leaving the case against Tornado Cash

The Court of Appeals accepted a joint motion that ends the dispute between the Treasure of the USA and Coin Center for the sanctions imposed on the crypto mixer.

***

• Court of Appeals accepted the motion to close the case Coin Center vs. US Treasury.
  
• He Treasure had reversed sanctions to Tornado cash In March.
  
• Coin Center He celebrates the decision as a victory against state overreach.

A Court of Appeals in the United States has definitely closed the legal dispute between the Treasury Department and Coin Center, which was related to the sanctions imposed on cryptocurrency mixer Tornado cash.

The Court of Appeals of the Eleventh Circuit It granted last week a joint motion presented by both parties to dismiss the case. The measure marks the official purpose of a judicial process that had generated broad debate in the crypto community on the legal scope of the US government regarding financial sanctions.

The case Tornado cash and the legal controversy

Tornado Cash, a protocol for the mixture of crypto transactions based on Ethereum, was sanctioned by the Treasury Foreign Assets Control Office (OFAC) In August 2022. With this action, American citizens and companies were prohibited to interact with the protocol, under the argument that it facilitated money laundering, even by malicious actors such as North Korean hackers.

However, the measure was widely criticized by legal experts and organizations defending digital rights. Coin Centera renowned research and defense center of the crypto sector, undertook a legal lawsuit against the Treasury Department, claiming that the sanction violated constitutional principles and exceeded the legal authority of the government.

The judicial decision and the withdrawal of sanctions

In a publication through your account in X, Peter van Valkenburgh, executive director of Coin Center, celebrated the closing of the case:

“This is the official end of our judicial battle on the legal authority behind the sanctions to Tornado Cash. The Government did not want to move forward or defend its dangerously broad interpretation of the sanctions laws”wrote.

The Department of the Treasury had reversed in March this year, formally removing the sanctions imposed on the protocol. In the joint motion presented last week, both parties agreed that this action made the pending appeal irrelevant.

“The government’s position is that the revocation of the designation by the OFAC makes this appeal lose meaning. For the plaintiffs, the appeal will be void once the Texas ruling is definitive and not appealable”indicated in the document reviewed by The Block.

Coin Center It has been one of the most active organizations in the defense of the legitimate use of decentralized technologies. Its opposition to the sanctions of Tornado cash It was based on the argument that the government should not sanction Autonomous Code or protocols without identifiable operators. This approach, according to the organization, feels a dangerous precedent that threatens the neutrality of digital tools.

The resolution of this case represents an important symbolic victory for the crypto ecosystem and its defenders, who feared a precedent that allowed the government to punish technological infrastructure without the need to prove specific criminal intention.

Implications for the future of technological sanctions

This episode has generated reflections within and outside the legal field on how financial sanctions should be applied to technological protocols. In a world where open source and decentralized platforms are increasingly common, the definition of legal responsibility becomes complex.

Although the Treasury Department He avoided continuing with the defense of his position in this case, the possibility of adopting new regulatory strategies in the future is open. For Coin Center And other similar organizations, the closure of this litigation represents a pause in tension, but not the end of the debate.

Article written by a content editor. Edited by Angel Di Matteo / Diariobitcoin

Original image of Diariobitcoin, created with artificial intelligence, for free use, licensed under public domain

WARNING: Diariobitcoin offers informative and educational content on various topics, including cryptocurrencies, AI, technology and regulations. We do not provide financial advice. Cryptactive investments are high risk and may not be adequate for all. Investigate, consult an expert and verify the applicable legislation before investing. I could lose all its capital.

Subscribe to our newsletter